Independent Board Evaluation
An independent board evaluation is an essential tool for enhancing board effectiveness and promoting good governance within an organisation. This evaluation process typically involves an impartial third party reviewing the performance of the board and its committees.
Conducting board evaluations independently provides many benefits. It ensures objectivity and neutrality, crucial factors in achieving a fair and unbiased assessment. It also brings an external perspective that can offer fresh insights and help to identify board strengths as well as opportunities for improvement.
The independent board evaluation should be comprehensive. It should focus on crucial areas like board governance, strategy, interactions amongst board members and board composition and development. Moreover, it contributes to increased transparency and trust, vital for enhancing shareholder confidence in the company’s leadership.

In our thought provoking Board Evaluation paper, you’ll discover:
✓ Why a Board evaluation is critical to the performance of an organisation.
✓ What are the core elements that make up the scope of an effective Board evaluation.
✓ A powerful approach that will build commitment to drive action within your organisation.
We help your Board get under the skin of what steps they need to take to provide maximum value to the business.
Our approach builds commitment and ownership, is relevant to the needs of your organisation and is inclusive, giving a voice to all Board members and key stakeholders.
We wanted a clear, tried and tested process that would identify recommendations that would help us improve as a Board. Mightywaters delivered on all fronts. They brought a clear approach which they delivered to plan. They worked collaboratively with the CEO and I throughout. They delivered an excellent report which has helped the Board develop a clear action plan to improve. Mightywaters grasped quickly the context we face and our strategic goals and were able to frame their recommendations accordingly. This has been a great piece of work and I highly recommend Mightywaters
Atholl Duncan
Chair
Mightywaters’ structured approach to Board effectiveness evaluation enabled Board members (who are from a joint venture of four mobile operators) to think deeply about their contribution and to reflect on what works well and where we need to refocus. The recommendations really added value and we are in the process of implementing them. I am very pleased with the outcomes of this work, it has exceeded my expectations
David Meyer
Chair
The Mightywaters Team
The Mightywaters Team has considerable experience in working with Boards. They developed the GIFT® framework through understanding the areas that drive Board effectiveness. They work across sectors and different governance codes, and often with organisations with unusual or complex shareholding / stakeholder arrangements.

Anna Withers
Founder and Director
Anna focuses on the psychology and neuroscience of work, providing specialist expertise in one-to-one coaching, counselling and conflict resolution, and in the use and interpretation of psychometric tools. She has a particular interest in decision making and in helping individuals and teams make better decisions.

Mark Withers
Founder and Director
Mark brings nearly four decades of business experience and works at the most senior organisational levels, helping leaders tackle their tough people and organisational challenges. He is also a highly skilled facilitator who is able to create environments that enable groups and teams of all sizes to collaborate, innovate, create and decide more effectively.
Does your Board have untapped potential?
Withers, A. (2019). Does your Board have untapped potential?. Ethical Boardroom, Autumn Issue.
A board effectiveness evaluation that gets under the skin of what’s working well and what’s getting in the way of peak performance is the perfect vehicle to help boards unlock this potential. But what does an effective board evaluation look like? Read Anna’s article published in Ethical Boardroom and find out why and how to conduct a board evaluation and the conditions for success.